2024 Dynasty Fantasy Baseball Rankings: September Top 500

Discover the top 500 players for dynasty fantasy baseball and gain an edge in your dynasty leagues.

Welcome to our 2024 dynasty fantasy baseball rankings! My Dynasty rankings focus on a three-year window. These rankings are designed to give you a good idea of how to draft a dynasty startup but also provide trade value. It is not perfect when negotiating a trade because every team is built differently, but this gives you a decent idea of where values lie when discussing trades.

A couple of important notes when looking at these rankings:

• With many dynasty leagues using saves+holds instead of saves, I value relievers that way for this list. In saves+holds, I would much rather wait on relievers with great ratios that will get holds since they are valued the same as saves. Therefore, you will find fewer relievers on my list than others. I try to tier the relievers based on skill level and the number of Sv/Hld they can provide.

• These rankings are designed for a 5x5 league with AVG. The spreadsheet has dynasty rankings for OBP leagues as well.

• For league type, I assume a 15-team, one-catcher league. In a shallower format, catchers become less valuable, and high-end players are more valuable because the replacement level is higher.

• These rankings factor in weekly lineup leagues.

• It is important to think about team build when using a dynasty list. If you are rebuilding or built to win in year 2, push prospects and younger players up.

• If you are built to win now, older players have much more value.

You can see the free top 50s below for every ranking set on the site. You can click below to get the Excel file or Google sheet for my full rankings which are top 500 for both prospects and dynasty in season and top 1000 during the offseason.

Free Rankings Google Sheet

Consider subscribing and supporting my work; you will get access to all our rankings plus multiple daily articles to help you win in dynasty.